Review: Harley Benton Ministar Testar electric travel guitar

Update (Mar 2014): If you have come here from a search engine, I should make you aware that unfortunately, Thomann stopped selling Harley Benton-branded Ministar guitars a few months ago. It appears I was fortunate to snap mine up when I did!
That said, as long as you are aware of the fact that you won’t be able to buy one of these guitars from Thomann—or, it seems, any other UK dealer, unfortunately—please feel free to read on…

Over the years, there have been all sorts of attempts to produce guitars which are designed primarily for “travel” use. I won’t waste time with a potted history (a Web search for “travel guitar” should give you more than enough to work through if you wish), but one of the more intriguing efforts, to my mind, is the Ministar range.

Photo of Harley Benton Ministar Testar electric guitar
Harley Benton Ministar Testar (with “body rods” fitted)

Conceived by guitarist and engineer Bob Wiley, an article on the Ministars at the Gizmag site describes them, not un-aptly, as “essentially a bunch of necks with pickups”, although this understates the ingenuity, and to a great extent, the practicality of the design. The full Ministar range runs the gamut of guitar types, from electrics (Strat, Tele, Les Paul, P90, jazz, etc.), electro-acoustics (steel- and nylon-string), hybrids (a 12-string with piezo and mag pickups) and basses (4- and 5-string, fretted and fretless). You can even buy “conversion kits” which turn your Ministar bass into an upright, or link together two Ministars of your choice into the most eye-catching double-neck guitar you’ll see all week.

Although the Ministars are relatively affordable (about $300 in the States), I discounted the idea of owning one due to being on a tiny budget. However, recently I learned to my great pleasure, that the German music retailer Thomann is currently selling a selection of Ministar models under their budget instrument brand Harley Benton.

You can guess the rest 🙂

I am reviewing my Harley Benton Ministar Testar HT (hard tail—i.e. no vibrato unit fitted) model, which I ordered from Thomann in early July for just under £90 (plus shipping). Hold that figure in your mind, as I will be coming back to it…

(Note: The above link points to a variant of the Testar fitted with a vibrato bridge. Just before I published this review, I found Thomann are no longer selling the “hard-tail” model that I own and am reviewing here, nor for that matter, most of the Harley Benton Ministars. All I can say is: if you really want one of these guitars, I’d get in there quickly, as for all I know, they may all vanish as quickly as the one I now own 😦 )

The guitar arrived in a pretty sizeable box, which turned out to be mostly air and large plastic bubble-wrap. In the middle of all this was a surprisingly small gig bag… was there really an electric guitar in there?

Indeed there was: remember the “neck-and-pickups” description of Ministar guitars from earlier? Well, that’s exactly what you get: imagine removing the body from a solid electric guitar, and you’re left with a “stick”-like instrument with the bridge and headstock at opposite ends.

Here is the Flickr photoset I created for the Testar, which gives you a pretty clear idea of how it looks:

Harley Benton Ministar Testar - close-up of pickup sectionHarley Benton Ministar Testar - in gig-bagHarley Benton Ministar Testar - built-in headphone ampHarley Benton Ministar Testar - without "body rods"Harley Benton Ministar Testar - with "body rods" and strap fittedHarley Benton Ministar Testar - frets close-up
Harley Benton Ministar Testar - on stand, full viewHarley Benton Ministar Testar - on stand, closer viewHarley Benton Ministar Testar - on stand, from aboveHarley Benton Ministar Testar - on stand, close-up of pickupsHarley Benton Ministar Testar - on stand, another close-upHarley Benton Ministar Testar - on stand, headstock view
Harley Benton Ministar Testar with Roland Micro Cube amp - on stage

Harley Benton Ministar Testar, a set on Flickr.

You can see from some of the photos, how the guitar is set up so it can be played comfortably, even without a body: you install a pair of what I’d call “body rods”, from which you can hang a regular guitar strap. One rod includes a wooden block, which gives the player’s right arm something to lean against—as you’ll read shortly, this really makes a difference to playing comfort, and it’s a sign of the thought that I feel has gone into designing Ministar instruments.

(In passing: one accessory that Harley Benton’s Ministars don’t include—but the “originals” apparently do—is an alternative “body rod”, which I’d call a “knee rest”, and which makes the Ministar more comfortable to play sitting down. I was able to order one from Play Away Guitars, who had one in their “spares box”—the knee rest is a nice-to-have, although the Testar feels rather headstock-heavy due to the centre of gravity being quite far back towards the pickups. Also, because the rod is secured via a knurled bolt, it is also a bit of a pain in the proverbial to have to swap the knee rest for the other strap-rod, if you want to play standing up again. A rod which combined both functions would be great—so you could stand up and sit down at will—but I can’t see how it would be possible, given the Ministar’s current design.)

Electrical controls on the Testar are straightforward: two small toggle switches on the “top” side, for pickup selection and for switching in/out an “out of phase” tone. I didn’t feel the latter made much difference to the sound (the “neck” pickup is perhaps a little brighter-sounding with it activated), but it doesn’t hurt to have the option. The tone and volume pots—the latter “nested” on top of the other to save space—are, oddly, situated on the bottom edge of the guitar, but I don’t use either that regularly, and I quickly got used to finding them by touch. The tone control is more or less “on or off” rather than a smooth “logarithmic” effect, so I tend to leave it alone unless I’m using an EBow, where the tone needs to be “treble-off”.

On the back of the Testar is the SCAMP headphone amplifier, which unusually runs off two “watch”-style lithium button cells (presumably to save space—there’s very little of it on a Ministar). I wasn’t expecting much, but the SCAMP is rather more usable than I expected—it’s nicely quiet, with little extraneous noise. There are really only two tone-settings—a crystalline “clean”, and a pretty raucous “crunch” overdrive—but I found both quite listenable. If practising, if I wanted more than a basic tone, I’d be more likely to run the Ministar’s output into my iPhone (with TASCAM iU2 interface and JamUp Pro XT for effects/amp-sim) for practice and/or recording, but for a quick plug-in-phones-and-go blast, the SCAMP is dead-easy to operate and sounds fine to my ears. An option to route the Testar’s pickup output through the SCAMP en route to the main jack out, wouldn’t go amiss, but I won’t lose sleep over its absence.

I found the guitar’s finish to be quite acceptable, especially given the price. The fret-edges are well-filed, although some felt a bit rough on the surface when bending strings—I guess, probably nothing that a fret-dressing wouldn’t fix. Moreover, I found the playing action just about right for me; neither too high nor too low, and probably the most comfortable I’ve yet found on a budget electric.

Playing

When I bought the Testar, I admit my expectations were not high, largely because of its low cost. For me, if it was cheap, compact and played/sounded acceptable, that was all that I sought—basically, a “back-up” electric guitar that I could stow in an airline locker or car-boot, for the hotel room, caravan, etc. How well can a £90 guitar play/sound, especially when it’s effectively a neck-and-pickups suspended from two metal rods?

In short: far better than I could have hoped or imagined. In fact, I’ve found myself wanting to play my Ministar as often as my Steinberger S-series—it’s only when I “have” to use the Steiny’s Roland GK pickup (for MIDI guitar, or VG-8 use) that the Testar has to stay in its gig-bag. (I don’t see how it could be possible to fit a GK-compatible pickup in a Ministar, unless it was an Axon piezo-type system and there were no other electronics installed… now there’s a project!)

With the strap-rods at least, the Ministar feels well-balanced, and the wooden block on the “back” rod is placed in the right location for the right elbow to rest against. I can’t say that the overall “feel” of the Ministar when being played, will suit all guitarists, but I have got used to it quite quickly. Understandably, the guitar is also very light—if I’m standing up with my Steinberger for more than about half an hour, I end up with backache for a few hours, so the Ministar’s lack of bulk in such situations is most welcome. (I think I’m reaching the point where I’ll need to sit down when playing the Steiny—not very rock’n’roll, unless you’re Robert Fripp 😉 )

Sound-wise: in terms of electronics, scale, etc., the Testar is based on the Fender Telecaster, and to my ears it does a fine job of impersonating the Tele’s bright twang, which was what I was looking for all along. Metallers would probably want to look elsewhere, but running the Testar through various amp-simulators, I was able to get the kind of tones I like (from Jack Johnson-esque clean to Status Quo-style crunch).

Overall, the guitar feels and sounds to me more like an instrument costing two to three times as much as it did—in other words, more in line with the kind of price one would pay for a “real” Ministar in the US. I would be curious to find out whether these Harley Benton Ministars are cheaper “licensed copies”, or whether Thomann has basically sourced some “real” Ministar guitars (perhaps from the same factory) and simply added the HB logo onto them. I have no proof, but my experience of my HB Testar would suggest the latter—it feels, plays and sounds to me like a guitar costing £200-300, rather than £90, and Thomann are known for some very keen pricing on the products they sell.

Verdict

As I said above, I had modest expectations when I found the Harley Benton Ministar Testar. My priorities for an electric “travel guitar” were: a very low price; more than one pickup (preferably in Tele configuration); and small size for travelling with. The Testar ticked all these boxes; I didn’t expect such a guitar to play and/or sound well at this price point, but if it did, that would be a welcome bonus.

As should be clear by now, the Testar has surpassed comfortably what expectations I held for it. Not only is it the ideal electric guitar for carrying around with me, but I have found myself going to it for both recording and live use, even in preference to my Steinberger (which, whilst being a terrific guitar, is rather big and heavy, especially when standing with it). I would consider another Ministar if I was seeking a new electric guitar (though I hasten to add I’m quite happy with what I have for the foreseeable future).

In short, if you are seeking an especially-portable instrument for taking on your travels, and you are open to an unusual-looking instrument which may feel different to the “norm”, I highly recommend checking out Ministar guitars, especially if you live in Europe and Thomann are still selling them by the time you read this. The Harley Benton Ministars are a total bargain, though if you are UK-based and want to look into the “proper” Ministar range, Play Away Guitars sometimes stocks them (and they’re a great retailer for travel-sized guitars, ukuleles and so on anyway).

One more dilemma: because it lacks a GK2 pickup (and there’s no room for one), I can’t use my Testar with my venerable Roland VG-8EX… which means that for live (and possibly recording) use, I’m now interested in a keenly-priced multi-FX with amp-sims, tons of FX models, USB audio interface capability, 40-second looper, XLR output and more. ZOOM: don’t you dare discontinue the G3 for a couple of months… 😉

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Review: Harley Benton Ministar Testar electric travel guitar

  1. Hi!
    Thanks for the review.

    Based on your experience if I was looking for a more “authentic” fender sound, do you think the pickups can be change?

    Thanks.

    1. Hi Martin – sorry for the delay in coming back to your comment. I think the Ministar sounds quite “Fender-ish” as it is (complete with pickup buzz 😦 ), but I can’t see why the pickups couldn’t be replaced, as long as you were reasonably experienced with that sort of job (or knew someone who was). Myself: I’m not, so personally I think I’ll stick with the pickups on there…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s